Court Rules Consistently with HTI Amicus on Sentencing Guidelines for Traffickers

On August 9, 2021, a federal appeals court agreed with HTI’s recommendations submitted last year in an amicus curiae (or “friend of the court”) brief, or a legal document providing third-party assistance and background to the court. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta, Georgia upheld a 121-month prison sentence for Alvero Valdez, who pled guilty in 2019 to conspiring to traffic a 15-year-old girl for sex. In its amicus brief, HTI asked the appellate court to affirm the decision of the lower court in order to avoid undermining the sentencing structure set by Congress. These guidelines recommend punishments that reflect the severity of human trafficking crimes.

The appellate court found the original sentence was reasonable, contrary to Valdez’s appeal. This decision means the District Court for the Southern District of Florida accurately interpreted the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines to arrive at the correct “base offense level.” The base offense level sets the starting point for judges to determine the seriousness of an offense and calculate the corresponding sentencing range. By agreeing the sentence is a reasonable length, the appeals court sets a standard for other courts to follow regarding how to apply the guidelines when sentencing serious trafficking crimes. 

HTI’s amicus brief was authored by Director of Legal Engagement Lindsey Roberson, former Associate Legal Counsel Kyleigh Feehs, and Associate Legal Counsel Alyssa Currier Wheeler with support from former Legal Intern Tyler Miko. Read the full brief here.

HTI submits multiple amicus briefs each year to provide recommendations to courts as they make significant decisions about how to best apply the U.S. human trafficking laws. In this way, HTI helps U.S. courts set standards for holding suspected traffickers accountable. When traffickers are penalized for exploiting victims, it sends traffickers a message that their crimes are not worth the risk.

About the author

Emma coordinates external content sharing to cultivate relationships with donors and encourage the general public to support HTI’s work. Before coming to HTI, Emma worked as a consultant with the Alliance to End Slavery and Trafficking. Her work included crafting federal appropriations recommendations and co-writing a presidential transition report, alongside numerous writing projects centered on counter-human trafficking advocacy. Emma was also an intern for Illinois State Representative Kelly Cassidy where she performed research for upcoming legislation. She received a B.A. in Global Studies from the University of Chicago.

You Might Also Like

Published by

Emma Ecker

Emma coordinates external content sharing to cultivate relationships with donors and encourage the general public to support HTI’s work. Before coming to HTI, Emma worked as a consultant with the Alliance to End Slavery and Trafficking. Her work included crafting federal appropriations recommendations and co-writing a presidential transition report, alongside numerous writing projects centered on counter-human trafficking advocacy. Emma was also an intern for Illinois State Representative Kelly Cassidy where she performed research for upcoming legislation. She received a B.A. in Global Studies from the University of Chicago.